NGOs Issue Joint Appeal on Behalf of Refugees Held Hostage in Sinai Desert

Agenzia Habeshia, EveryOne Group, Human Rights Concern Eritrea and Christian Solidarity Worldwide today sent a joint appeal to the UN, the EU, the British, the Italian and the Egyptian governments for urgent intervention in the plight of refugees from Eritrea, Ethiopia, Sudan and Somalia who are currently held hostage in the Sinai Desert by Bedouin people traffickers. 

Hundreds of refugees from the Horn of Africa have been held for months on the outskirts of a town in Sinai in purpose-built containers, where people traffickers are demanding payment of up to US$8,000 per person for their release, though the hostages had already paid US$2,000 for passage to Israel. 

The appeal says that the refugees are being treated in an extremely degrading and inhumane manner. “They are bound by chains around their ankles, have been deprived of adequate food, are given salty water to drink, and have been tortured using extreme methods, including electric shocks, to force friends and families abroad to make the payments. The women in the group, who have been separated from the rest, are particularly vulnerable to severe abuse.”

The NGOs have been in direct contact with the group, whose situation has deteriorated markedly. Today nine people are reported to have suffered life-threatening injuries after receiving severe beatings, while ten others are seriously ill. The wounded are not receiving treatment, and the group has not eaten for three days. Over the weekend the refugees were branded like cattle, and on 28 November three Eritrean men were reportedly shot dead after their families confirmed to the kidnappers that they were unable to make the ransom payment. Three more hostages were reported to have died on 30 November following a severe assault administered by the traffickers in the aftermath of an escape attempt by a group of 12 refugees. 

The appeal continues, “The lives of hundreds of refugees currently appear to hang in the balance.  It is vital that key members of the international community make immediate and urgent representations to the Egyptian government to ensure that these refugees are rescued, and that every refugee in Egypt is afforded full protection and assistance.”

For a full transcript of the joint agency appeal see below.

.............................................................................................

For further information or to arrange interviews please contact

For Human Rights Concern Eritrea, contact Elizabeth Chryum, Director, This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.; www.hrc-eritrea.org

Kiri Kankhwende, Press Officer at Christian Solidarity Worldwide on +44 (0)20 8329 0045 / +44 (0) 78 2332 9663, email This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. or visit www.csw.org.uk.

For Agenzia Habeshia per la Cooperazione allo Sviluppo, contact Mr Mussie Zerai, Director, This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.; http://habeshia.blogspot.com

For EveryOne, contact Mr. Malini, Mr. Pegoraro and Mr. Picciau, Co-Presidents,

This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.; www.everyonegroup.com

For Christian Solidarity Worldwide, contact Andrew Johnston, Advocacy Director; www.csw.org.uk

……………….........................................................…………………………………………………

His Excellency Hosni Mubarak   
President of the Arab Republic of Egypt   
Abdin Palace   
Cairo   
Egypt                                                                               

Via fax: +20 22 390 1998

                                                           1 December 2010

Your Excellency,

We write to draw your attention to, and to appeal for, urgent intervention in the appalling plight of hundreds of refugees from Eritrea, Ethiopia, Sudan and Somalia who are currently held hostage in the Sinai Desert by Bedouin people traffickers.

These people have been held for months on the outskirts of a town in Sinai in purpose-built containers. Their captors are demanding payment of up to US$8,000 per person before releasing them, and are subjecting them to cruel, inhuman, and degrading treatment. They are bound by chains around their ankles, have been deprived of adequate food, are given salty water to drink, and have been tortured using extreme methods, including electric shocks, to force friends and families abroad to make these payments. The women in the group, who have been separated from the rest, are particularly vulnerable to severe abuse.  

Over the weekend the situation of these refugees appears to have deteriorated markedly. Hostages were branded like cattle, and on Sunday evening, three Eritrean men were reportedly shot dead after their families confirmed to the kidnappers that they were unable to meet the additional payments - the hostages had already paid US$2000.  

On Tuesday morning, three more hostages were reported to have died following a severe assault administered by the traffickers after a group of 12 attempted to escape. Hostages now report being beaten so badly that their backs are bloody and bruised.

Due to a series of human rights crises, the Horn of Africa in general and the Sinai in particular have now become major centres for people trafficking by highly organized crime syndicates. In a harrowing report recently compiled in Israel,¹ refugees recount the horrors that were inflicted on them at this purpose-built desert facility as traffickers attempted to elicit increasingly large sums of money from them, including systematic rape, electrocution, branding with hot metal, severe and sustained beatings and extrajudicial killing.  In August, AFP news agency reported the deaths of six Eritreans on the Egypt-Israel border, four of whom were killed in a dispute with people smugglers. In June, ten African refugees, including Eritreans, were reportedly killed by human smugglers in Sinai after they had been held for more than two months in these secret locations.

We find it inconceivable that large numbers of people who entitled to protection under international law are being forcibly detained by criminal gangs for such lengthy periods of time and with seeming impunity within Egyptian borders, without any official intervention. We are aware that Egypt's record with regard to the treatment of refugees has not been a good one, with numerous reports of inhumane imprisonment and the often fatal shootings of refugees on the border with Israel.  However, as current chair of the UNHCR's governing body and a signatory to the UN and African refugee conventions, Egypt has a duty to end this situation and to bring its treatment of refugees into line with international norms to which it is a signatory, while the international community has a duty to ensure that it upholds these norms. Moreover, the fact that the Sinai has now become a centre for people trafficking by organized criminal syndicates makes the fate of these and other refugees an international issue that key governments worldwide have a duty to address.   

The lives of hundreds of refugees hang in the balance.  It is vital that key members of the international community make immediate and urgent representations with the Egyptian government to ensure that these refugees are rescued, and that every refugee in Egypt is afforded full protection and assistance. 

We therefore make the following urgent appeal: 

To His Excellency Hosni Mubarak, President of the Arab Republic of Egypt: To take urgent action to tackle organized crime by rescuing these hostages, bringing their captors to justice, and permanently closing these torture camps.  It is also vital that Egypt brings its treatment of refugees into line with international legislation to which it is party, allows unhindered access to the UNHCR to all refugees, and ends practice of jailing of refugees, and shooting migrants on its border with Israel. 

To the British and Italian Foreign Ministers: to make urgent representations to the Egyptian government requesting swift action to ensure the safety of these refugees. 

To the European Commission and Council: To impress upon the government of Egypt in the context of the EU neighbourhood policy and political dialogue, the urgent need to rescue these hostages, to combat human trafficking, and to uphold its undertakings under international refugee conventions. The EU must also begin to earnestly address the root causes of migration², and to indeed do “everything in [its] power to target and fight this modern form of slavery”³ . 

To the European Commission and Council: To impress upon the government of Egypt in the context of the EU neighbourhood policy and political dialogue, the urgent need to rescue these hostages, to combat human trafficking, and to uphold its undertakings under international refugee conventions. The EU must also begin to earnestly address the root causes of migration2, and with regard to trafficking, to indeed do “everything in [its] power to target and fight this modern form of slavery”3 .  

To H.E. Mr. Sihasak Phuangketkeow, President of the UN Human Rights Council: To initiate an inquiry into human rights violations against these and other refugees in Egypt.